All through the 1930s, the vatican never once explicitly protested the nazi persecution and killing of the jews. Stalin took pius xiis encyclical as a declaration of war, and he answered as was his wont. Feb 26, 20 peter eisners book, the popes last crusade, tells the story of pope pius xi stance against the abuses of nazi germany and fascist italy, and his unsuccessful attempt to issue a papal encyclical condemning the abuses of jews by those regimes in the years just prior to world war ii. With pius xii, the why is more important than what. The secret history of pius xii is a less inflammatory book than its title suggests. At the same time, he was to pursue a reich concordat, a treaty between the. An interview with rabbi dalin historian rabbi david dalin of new york comes down on the side of pius xii. Instead of condemning this thug, pope pius offered hitler his full backing and support. He was not hitlers pope, but neither was he hitlers adversary. Neither pope pius xi nor hitler attended the meeting. When cardinal eugenio pacelli became pius xii in 1939, nazi ss chief heinrich himmler ordered albert hartl, a defrocked catholic priest, to prepare a dossier on the new pope. The implication in the title is that the pope was hitlers enabler. I got involved in that framing operation in october 1959, when khrushchev visited romania. Rychlaks work should put to an end the slander of a heroic pope who, more.
I would now argue, in the light of the debates and evidence following hitler s pope, that pius xii had so little scope of action that it is impossible to judge the motives for his silence during the war, while rome was under the heel of mussolini and later occupied by germany. Longburied vatican files reveal a new indictment of pope pius xii. In 1938, and the beginning of 1939, pope pius xi was weakened by heart disease which would eventually kill him, but he kept working even when bedridden. In the summer of 1944, after the liberation of rome but before the wars end, pius told a group of roman jews who had come to thank him for his protection. Five years after the publication of hitler s pope, cornwell stated. The relationship between the catholic church in italy and the countrys fascist regime began. Pius xii spoke out against the war on several occasions. The position that pius xii was a villain is taken despite the fact that pius xii did more than his detractors would have you believe. In pope pius xii and the holocaust, wellinformed scholarsincluding michael marrus, michael phayer, richard l. The claim that pius xii was friendly with, or at least passively acquiescent to, the nazi regime is an unquestioned dictum in new atheist circles. Pancratius pfeiffer to try to gain the release of the 1,259 jews arrested. Impressed with the writings of an american priest, father. In his book, dave convinced me that they are full of heresy and abominations, from catholicisms companionship with hitler to pope innocent 111 wiping out large multitudes of christians, as well as other popes who kil.
Pius xii not only opposed hitler but plotted against him, book says. Father chamberlain writes that the end of the hitlers pope myth has scarcely been noticed in britain. The ambassador went on to say that the play was far from being a serious exercise in the historical presentation of the late pius xii. What follows here are highlighted excerpts from cornwells book hitlers pope, with a link at the end of the article for you to click and read, as paul harvey would say, the rest of the story. Pope pius xii and his secret war against nazi germany. In the end, this book supports the conclusion of other studies, which have found that pope pius xii was not a saint. How pope pius xii rescued jews from the nazis in 2005. The book s main revelation for me was the close relationship between the blunt, outspoken achille ratti, as pope pius xi, and the deftly diplomatic eugenio pacelli, pope pius xii. What did pope pius xii think of benito mussolini and vice.
Now, diplomatic documents recently brought to light by a jesuit. The reichskonkordat concordat between the holy see and the german reich is a treaty negotiated between the vatican and the emergent nazi germany. The popes secret war against hitler basic books, 2015, he turns his meticulous attention to the whole matter of pope pius xii and what he really did or. Hitlers first foreign treaty of all was with pope pius xii in 1933. The holocaust and the catholic church the atlantic. Pius xiis daring efforts to kill adolf hitler and end his genocidal regime. A christmas day editorial in the new york times praised pius xii for his moral leadership in opposing the nazis. The secret history of pius xii, by john cornwall pius xii and the second world war. He reaffirmed previous accounts of pius having been a saviour of thousands of europes jews. In retaliation, in the fall of 1942, goebbelss office distributed ten million copies of a pamphlet naming pius xii as the projewish pope and explicitly citing his interventions in france.
Pius xi issued numerous encyclicals, including quadragesimo anno on the 40th anniversary of pope leo xiiis groundbreaking social encyclical rerum novarum, highlighting the capitalistic greed of international finance, the dangers of socialismcommunism, and social justice issues, and quas primas, establishing the feast of christ the king in response to anticlericalism. Ralph mcinernys book titled the defamation of pius xii is yet another refutation of the attempts to smear pope pius xii as an agent of hitler and the. The documents discovered at santa maria dellanima also showed how pius xii used the threat to speak out against hitler and the nazis in order to end the arrest of the roman jews. This book gives the most complete and best documented account of pius xii and. Hitlers pope is a book published in 1999 by the british journalist and author john cornwell that examines the actions of eugenio pacelli, who became pope pius xii, before and during the nazi era, and explores the charge that he assisted in the legitimization of adolf hitler s nazi regime in germany. Vatican hopes secret files exonerate hitlers pope world. His reign as pope coincided with the rise of hitler and the nazi party to political power in germany. Foreword john cardinal oconnor the papacy and the world hitler and the postwar world the spread of nationalism the lateran treaty hitlers rise to power world unrest hitler battles the churches the violence spreads prewar pope 1939 and the outbreak of war 1940 and the nazis press on 1941 and the new enemies 1942. Rychlaks hitler, the war and the pope, michael phayers the catholic church and the holocaust, 19301965, susan zuccottis under his very windows, ralph mcinernys the defamation of pius xii, and, most recently, james. Is the world finally admitting the truth about pope pius xii.
Pope pius xiis 18761958 actions during the holocaust remain controversial. The debate should be settled for good now that new research shows the vatican not only saved the lives of thousands of jews, but also worked to assassinate hitler. Pope and mussolini tells the secret history of fascism and the church historian david kertzer says the catholic church lent strength and legitimacy to mussolinis fascist regime. Several books have been published which suggest that pius was complacent and supportive of the national socialist movement of the era, among which is cambridge university professor john corwells book, hitlers pope. John cornwall indicts pope pius xii for aiding and abetting the nazis in order to consolidate his power over the catholic church. May 04, 2019 what follows here are highlighted excerpts from cornwells book hitlers pope, with a link at the end of the article for you to click and read, as paul harvey would say, the rest of the story. According to the archives of the vatican by pierre blet, s. As early as 1915, he had been part of a vatican delegation in vienna, trying to negotiate a peace treaty to end the first world war. In league with two trusted priests and joey ox, pope pius xii took an active role in encouraging anti hitler plots in germany, and although the pontiff never put out a hit like a mafia don, he. The popes secret war against hitler, mark riebling uses newly released vatican files and secret transcripts, vividly describing the cloakanddagger tactics pius xii employed to. Hartl documented how pacelli had used the concordat he had negotiated with hitlers new government in 1933 to the churchs advantage, complaining formally to hitler at least fiftyfive times about violations. The title is deliberate, the implication substantially proved by the author, british historian john cornwell, a practicing catholic who has fallen foul of the vatican and other leading members of the hierarchy since. Eugenio pacelli, pope pius xii, has long been the subject of controversy over his failure to speak out against hitler s final solution. Hitlers pope less inflammatory book than title suggests.
Longburied vatican files reveal a new indictment of pope. The software translates that quite a few like to learn to read this book. The real story of pius xii and the jews by james bogle jewish dauchaus priests the weekly standard. The flaws in cnns episode on pius xii catholic league. The popes secret war against hitler appeared last year, it earned widespread acclaim. The explosive the new york times bestsellernow with a new introduction by the authorwhen hitlers pope, the shocking story of pope pius xii that redefined the history of the twentieth century the washington post was originally published, it sparked a firestorm of controversy both inside and outside the catholic church. In hitler s pope, awardwinning journalist and roman catholic john cornwell shows that, even well before the holocaust, pope pius xii was instrumental in negotiating an accord that helped the nazis rise to unhindered powerand sealed the fate of the jews in. The buzz about the book see what people are saying about hitler, the war, and the pope. His predecessor, pope pius xi, trashed hitlers notion of aryan supremacy in the encyclical cowritten by the future pius xii entitled mit brennender sorge.
Pope pius xii was silent in the face of nazi atrocities against the jews during world war ii, and that silence led to the deaths of many innocent people. The usefulness of daniel goldhagen his new book attacking pope pius xii is filled with factual errors, providing an opportunity for other anticatholic writers to claim the middle ground the good samaritan. The pope would have been believed, whereas the broadcasts of the allies were often shrugged off as war propaganda. Published october 26th 2000 by penguin books first published august 28th 1999. Most of his sources are secondary and written by pacellis harshest critics. Aug 31, 2003 pope pius xii has been branded by some authors and jewish leaders as hitler s pope for his silence during the holocaust. How pius xii was an active conspirator in three anti. Near the end of my research i found myself in a state i can only describe as moral shock. What follows here are highlighted excerpts from cornwells book hitlers pope1, with a link at the end of the article for you to click and read, as paul harvey would say, the rest of the story. What follows here are highlighted excerpts from cornwells book hitlers pope1, with a link at the end of the article. At the center of goldhagens anticatholic thesis is the piece of evidence that john cornwell centrally relied upon in his deeply flawed book, hitlers pope. Longburied vatican files reveal a new and shocking indictment of world war ii s pope pius xii. The secret history of pius xii by john cornwell is a fascinating but disturbing book about pope pius xii eugenio pacelli, who reigned from 1939 to 1958 and was the pope during the first nine years of my life. Hitlers pope is a provocative title for a biography of eugenio pacelli, better known as pope pius xii.
Pope pius xii and his secret war against nazi germany dalin, david g. A fastpaced historical narrative explores just how far the catholic church went in collaborating with italys. Anyone interested in the papacy must read this fascinating book. And the 80th anniversary of the reichskonkordat is a timely occasion for a fresh look at how that agreement. Now a british author has unearthed extensive material that vatican. Hitler responded that germany was entitled to the area because of the shameful way in which the treaty of versailles, which had ended world war i, in rome, the society of jesusa roman catholic missionary organizationreceives its charter from pope paul iii. Longburied vatican files reveal a new and shocking indictment of world war iis pope pius xii. Dec 18, 2016 pope pius xiis secret support for the attempted overthrow of nazi dictator adolf hitler is the subject of a new book that draws on wartime documents and interviews with the american intelligence. What it did was bring to an end something of a cold war in relations between the church and the german state, which had been going on since the time of bismarck.
At the time hitler rose to power there were 23 million german catholics. Cornwells book is a vicious attempt at a moral lynching and a real character assassination. The secret history of pius xii new ed by john cornwell isbn. Pope pius xiis alleged silence in the face of the destruction of the european jews during world war ii has been the subject of a fierce controversy that has continued unabated ever since rolf hochhuths the deputy made the charge so spectacularly in. Nov 01, 20 the kremlins framing of pius xii began on june 3, 1945, when radio moscow insinuated that pius xii was hitlers pope. The hound of hitler is a highly original study of the exercise of political and religious power, of realpolitik and the there is a claim that hitlers rise to power was left unchallenged by the inaction of pope pius xii. Mar 18, 2019 headline final word yet to be written on pius xii. Pius xiis secret war against hitler the catholic thing. Listeners on both sides of the war understood that this was a direct reference to the jews. Five years after the publication of hitlers pope, cornwell stated. Feb 09, 20 pius xii has long been vilified as hitler s pope, accused of failing publicly to condemn the genocide of europes jews. Piux xii was not, as the title of one book about him charges, hitlers pope. I would now argue, in the light of the debates and evidence following hitlers pope, that pius xii had so little scope of action that it is impossible to judge the motives for his silence during the war, while rome was under the heel of mussolini and later occupied by germany.
This is despite the fact the claim pius xii was hitlers pope is a total distortion of history. Six years earlier, in a book entitled a thief in the night, i had defended the. This 1999 book was wellresearched using recently released vatican documents from that period, and informative. For much of the war, he maintained a public front of indifference and remained silent while german atrocities were committed. The popes secret war against hitler, rieblings research unveils a series of plots and acts of espionage involving pope pius that sought to bring down the tyrannical. The book goes further than any before in accusing pius xii of failing to. Sep 01, 2003 the vatican concordat with hitler s reich.
No christmas sermon reaches a larger congregation than the message pope pius xii addresses to a wartorn world at this season. Pope pius xii the reader wiki, reader view of wikipedia. The end of faith by sam harris the origins of totalitarianism by hannah arendt. New look at pius xiis views of nazis the new york times. According to the archives of the vatican, by pierre blet. The astonishing secret history of the pope who fought hitler. The secret history of pius xii viking, 1999 i feel guilty abandoning this book. One expert has said that when it comes to pope pius xii and the controversy surrounding his actions during the second world war, his actions are far less appealing to historical scholars than the. Hitlers pope is a book published in 1999 by the british journalist and author john cornwell that examines the actions of eugenio pacelli, who became pope pius xii, before and during the nazi. The secret history of pius xii new ed by cornwell, john isbn. No longer a disparager of pius xii inside the vatican.
Cornwall does not argue that pius xiiwho was pope during the. A number of folks are really hunting for this unique book. It is a letter, written in 1919 by eugenio pacelli, the future pope pius xii, when he was papal nuncio in munich. Rubenstein and susan zuccottiwrestle with these questions. Here is an excellent article, however, that provides enlightenment to the situation and his response. Browse the amazon editors picks for the best books of 2019, featuring our favorite reads in more than a. Pius xii not only opposed hitler but plotted against him. How pope pius xii became hitlers pope catholic answers. Hitlers pope is a book published in 1999 by the british journalist and author john cornwell that examines the actions of eugenio pacelli, who became pope pius xii, before and during the nazi era, and explores the charge that he assisted in the legitimization of adolf hitlers nazi regime in germany, through the pursuit of a reichskonkordat in 1933. Pope pius xiis own love for germany had deep roots. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. Pope pius xii is pictured at the vatican in a file photo dated march 15, 1949. Well written and meticulously researched, rieblings book highlights a series of longforgotten episodes from world war ii.
Xii and the second world war, garry willss papal sin, margherita marchiones pope pius xii, ronald j. To end the myth is simply not politically correct, not in britain, not anywhere. He became pope of the roman catholic church on february 6, 1922 and died february 10, 1939. Pope pius xi was born on may 31, 1857 in desio, italy as ambrogio damiano achille ratti. Pope pius xii conducted a covert war against the nazis during world war. When the pope tried to kill hitler catholic league. Moreover, the book s cover photo is not of pope pius xii visiting the third reich but of the thenarchbishop pacelli as nuncio to germany in 1927 six full years before hitler came to power in. May 30, 2019 the claim that pius xii was friendly with, or at least passively acquiescent to, the nazi regime is an unquestioned dictum in new atheist circles. A firm and final indictment of pius xiis papacy, hitlers pope is also a searing. In the end, cornwells assertion that he began his book as a defense of the pius xii is difficult to accept. Several historians have interpreted the conclave to choose his successor as facing a choice between a diplomatic or a spiritual candidate, and they view pacellis diplomatic experience, especially with germany, as one of the deciding factors in his election on 2 march 1939, his 63rd birthday, after only one day of deliberation and three ballots. When cornwells book, hitlers pope, was published in 1999, it alleged that pius was seemingly prepared to put up with any nazi atrocity because he saw hitler as a good bulwark against the advance.
Pope pius xii and mussolini, 19381943 by harry schnitker, ph. Jan, 2016 thus was hatched a plan to construct an espionage network that would support, among other things, plots to assassinate hitler. Cornwells portrayal of pius xii is a nasty caricature of a noble and saintly man. Pius xi and the rise of adolf hitler iii publishing. For 50 years, the truth about pius xiis battle against nazism has been suppressed. Pope pius xii helped hitler destroy german catholic political opposition. Hitler, the war, and the pope university of mississippi. I know im being pessimistic and cynical, but part of me says im simply being realistic. The concordat of 1933 was ambiguous in its day and remains so. Oct 29, 20 longburied vatican files reveal a new and shocking indictment of world war iis pope pius xii. It is an eye opener regarding the inner workings of the vatican. The pope pius xii controversy intercollegiate studies. In hitlers pope, awardwinning journalist and roman catholic john cornwell shows that, even well.
505 1458 1338 430 927 101 417 625 492 1315 1305 1230 549 709 126 1580 1264 173 850 899 1340 1322 822 1523 1575 360 1338 46 659 908 595 809 1019 138 520 1171 1123 545 720 782